BBC finds Panorama Wi-Fi report ‘misleading’

BBC finds Panorama Wi-Fi report ‘misleading’



December 4, 2015

A recent Panorama report, which claimed that Wi-Fi creates three times as much radiation as mobile phone masts, has been found to be misleading by the BBC’s editorial complaints unit (ECU).

The ECU found that the programme gave a “misleading impression of the state of scientific opinion”.

Following the programme, two viewers complained to the BBC that Panorama had exaggerated the risk and that its suggestion that Wi-Fi was responsible for higher levels of radiation than phone masts was wrong.

It was also alleged that the programme’s presentation of an experiment to test whether certain people were hypersensitive to radiation from Wi-Fi, was misleading.

One of the contributors to the programme, Professor Michael Repacholi, complained that his view had been represented unfairly, and that the scientific issues were not presented with due consideration to both sides of the argument.

The ECU ruled that Panorama legitimately focused on public health issues raised by Sir William Stewart, chairman of the Health Protection Agency, and that an experiment on electro-sensitivity was correctly presented as being inconclusive.

However, the ECU also noted that the programme included only one contributor who disagreed with Sir William Stewart’s point of view, while three scientist and several others supported his concerns. It said that this gave a misleading impression of scientific opinion on the issue.

In the programme, Sir William Stewart said there was evidence that low-level radiation from devices such as mobile phones and Wi-Fi could damage health, and called for a review. This claim was dismissed by several experts following the broadcast.

The BBC’s commissioning editor for TV and Current Affairs has discussed the ECU’s report with the Panorama team, and highlighted the importance of reflecting the weight of scientific opinion effectively.

Tim Yeo

Related Posts

Bharti Airtel reports strong Q4

Comments Off on Bharti Airtel reports strong Q4

KPN launches UK business partner programme

Comments Off on KPN launches UK business partner programme

Siemens and Polycom in UC partnership

Comments Off on Siemens and Polycom in UC partnership

Be to raise network coverage by 15%

Comments Off on Be to raise network coverage by 15%

Orange offers free netbook with mobile broadband

Comments Off on Orange offers free netbook with mobile broadband

iPlayer-via-cable huge hit for Virgin Media

Comments Off on iPlayer-via-cable huge hit for Virgin Media

Salira unveils Flexible Multi-Wavelength Solution

Comments Off on Salira unveils Flexible Multi-Wavelength Solution

Occam Networks offers double blade

Comments Off on Occam Networks offers double blade

Vodafone and 3 merge in Australia

Comments Off on Vodafone and 3 merge in Australia

Sky Completes Switch to Provide Email via Google

Comments Off on Sky Completes Switch to Provide Email via Google

Synnex issuing US$200 million in new shares

Comments Off on Synnex issuing US$200 million in new shares

WiMAX could be launched in Taiwan as early as June

Comments Off on WiMAX could be launched in Taiwan as early as June

Create Account



Log In Your Account